Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition

Lot: 135941
Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition
Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition
Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition
Winning Bid: £4,000.00

Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition

Old Times
Kentucky, USA
Cask Type:
Bottle Strength:
100 US Proof
Bottle Size:
1/5 Gallon
Distillery Status:

Mammoth Cave 1895 Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon / Pre-Prohibition

Mammoth Cave is a bourbon brand with a storied history. This was distilled all the way back in 1895 at what was then called the Old Times, registered distillery number 1 in the 5th district of Kentucky. The Old Times distillery, built in 1869 changed hands several times over the years, and was eventually sold off two years after this was distilled, and renamed Willow Creek. A new Old Times was built across the street, and by 1901 had been renamed Number One distillery. This was bottled in bond there in 1914. The distillery was one of the hundreds that did not survive the Prohibition era, when the production and sale of alcohol was made illegal in the US, and closed its doors for good in 1920.

This is a Bottled in Bond whiskey, which means that by law the whiskey had to be the product of a single distilling season, the date of distillation and bottling must be displayed, as must the distillery in which both took place. Additionally, all bottles had a required alcoholic strength of 100 US proof. The Bottled in Bond Act was passed two years after this was distilled, in 1897 and the campaign for its ratification was spearheaded by none other than a certain Colonel E.H. Taylor Jr. The purpose of the act was to ensure a legal standard of quality, and a definition for what could be described as bourbon whiskey. The Act was fiercely opposed by "Rectifiers," who produced cheap whiskey using grain neutral spirits and flavourings.

One such Rectifier was the W.L Weller and Sons company who, following the success of the Bottled in Bond Act eventually turned to the business of legitimate distilling. They would go on to purchase the Mammoth Cave brand at the onset of Prohibition, and bottled it as a medicinal product (a legal loophole that permitted whiskey sales during Prohibition, by a select few licensees), using whiskey procured from the A.Ph. Stitzel distillery, an important relationship that would lead to the creation of the legendary Stitzel-Weller in 1935.

Most examples of Mammoth Cave still in existence today are from this later W.L Weller period, and this pre-prohibition bottling from the Old Times distillery is an incredible artefact from the history of American whiskey.


Currency Estimate

Important: Currency exchange rates are constantly changing; this feature is to be used as a guide price only. All final transactions occur in British Pounds (£).
  • Water damage to labels and seal.
  • Fill level is mid shoulder.
  • Due to it's age this bottle is particularly fragile, Whisky Auctioneer Ltd cannot be held liable for any leakage/damage caused whilst the bottle is in transit, including lots sent using Risk Free Shipping. Collection is advised.
Important Notice

We would recommend viewing/close inspection prior to placing any bids. If this is not an option and you have questions beyond the offered description and images, please contact us for a more in-depth condition report. Otherwise lots will be sold as seen in the images.

Please note: Due to the various ages of bottles and their seals, condition of liquid is at the buyer's discretion and no claim can be lodged against failure/leakage in transit.

June Auction starts this Friday, 21st June 2019 from 1pm BST. Bottle deadline for July Auction is Monday 15th July 2019.

Contact Us

Whisky Auctioneer Ltd
West Building
Ruthvenfield Grove
Inveralmond Industrial Estate
United Kingdom

Tel: 01738 245576


Opening Times: Mon-Sat 10am-5pm